K|{|ur {p y|y r? My~y r~
u~~y tu| |yq {ryu|r
u ry} {
}yrp~~}
t~y{p}, |yq ~y ru y} {p{ Osp~ r~
u~~y tu| Rp~{-Puuq
sp t|wp rz~
yr }p{uy~srz {}p~yy Lpz-yx-C
t, ~rp~~z Q}p~} Bpy|u~{, y~p~~z y~ruyy~~z {}p~yy Cu}u (yz{
p {z ~y p|y rxrp yx~
y } rus psu~p pzy~y{p {}p~yy Ersu~y Npqzu~{, {z
{p| tu~sy {|yu~r r}uu ry}y tu|~y{p}y-prp~yu|}y, qry~yr r } ~ury~~ |tuz). @ p{wu uqyu|{s {upyrp Au Buz, pr} ytuy {s p{wu r|u Bpy|u~{. K|{|ur {p y|y r? Wu| rz~ xprp p{yrr {upyrp Au Buz q|uu u} ~p 4 }|t
q|uz, {u ~pt ~p purp~~ up {upyrp, y p{yrr p~ |y ~p y}u~ p{
wu
}}
. Hprp r y~uup {
y~ur, {u p yry y p{yr, ~urxyp ~p tu~sy {upyrp tu~sy pzy{r. B } y|u tu~sy u~
p~y{r RBO, {u xpyp Qty~
~p rz~u, p y tu~sp}y r |
ry }u~~z quutu|. ^
u
~
p{y {rpu }y~y r~
u~~y tu| Qyy |yq }
, ~ p} y us |y~p {}p~tp xp y}
s|r~} tu|}, |yq }
, ~ |~ xpryy}, {p{ }y~y}
} y~}py~~, {}p~t yu{s s|pr{p MBD. K
tp ytu
t B
p |z u~ r Rruu Uutupyy, }y~y r~
u~~y tu| B|pty}y K|{|ur p{pxrp| p{ ~pxrpu}}
s|r~} tu|u Lpz-yx-C
t Cu}u Au Buz, qup| }y||ypt
q|uz
uqp y tu{y uury. Pu-|
wqp MBD t
{rtr} us qurz t
sy Iy~ B|{ xpry|p }, r{p tuu|~ {
~uzuz r yyy Qyy y~p~rz yp}yt. Ot~p{ r
s|r~} tu|u, p|utrp~~} y|y, ru~uu {pxp, yxsr|u~~} CRT yu{s s|pr{p MBD, {u r urp|u ~pp| p}pyrp Py}{yz pz~~z
t Rp~{-Puuq
sp, 282 }|~
q|uz
uqp y 221 |y, yx~p~~u |utryu} uury}: ~y{p{y }y||yptr y tu{r uury. Py } tpwu p{yu qry~u~y pp r tu
tuq~s |utry, {u }pp ytu r Py}{} pz~~}
tu. Ny uty~s t{
}u~p, truwtpus xyy |utry y qry~u~y, ~u utpr|u~. Sp{ ~pxrpu}u uuryu
wu q yty r
t ~p |ut~uu xputp~yu uut }u~} |u~y} uur} ~u ry| ~y ty~ yx p{ ~pxrpu} uury. Puuryu y ptpryu A|y~r uury ~p
tu xpr|
}} {| 12 }|~
q|uz, y } r tu
tuq~s |utry r~u, ~y, {p{ pry|, |
p|y ~u}p|z tt, yu} ~y uu y ~p|sru/rp|~u u
~y{y, p{ {p{ tt ~u tu{|pyrp|y. Ruty uury u spwtp~u, xpr|yu }ur~u
}} r 5070 ., u {|yur uury uyp|~ ~p{
yrp| |utryu}. I tpwu y} ~p{
yrp~yu}
tp| ~pqp p{ }p|
yrp,
Cu}up, tp~~} p}s wu |utry, q|uu 200 . {|yu~r r Qyy, p r {upyru Au Buz {| 20 . pzy{r. S u q|y~r y {|yu~r Cu}up, y pzy{r {upyrp ~u yp uq uury}y tuu|~y y sp~yxpyz. R
t p} qpu~yz r ru y~p~yy, ~u{|{y} r|~p} }yy~sr, {pyry Qyy, ~y yp uq uury}y tuu|~y sp~r r~
u~~y tu|. But y}u~~ xpruqrp~~z yu{y} T^AyPK ypt}y~ yz{z |puw~z yu} Cu}up Npqzu~{ xpq|{yrp| y pxs}y| r urp|u 2022 stp
|puw~
yu}
, ruyr ~p pzu ty{|uz}u: Oqppzu r prp~yu|~u sp~, ~p }u u{py| rrt utr. I}u~~ tuzry prp~yu|~ sp~r r ~u~yy {}p~yy t y |u xp
t~y|y rrt tu~us. Du| r }, t| rrtp utr }~sy}y y|xrp| }up~yx} p2p, xr|yz ~u |py {}yy, u t| rrtp utr ~
w~, q {- r~y| tu~sy (, ~~, ux{ {py| yx-xp
s|r~s tu|p) y yty| q}u~. Ot~p{ q ~u uty~ru~~z, rrt utr p{ y|y y~pu
ur|u. Sy pzy{r {upyrp u} q|uu ~u yp uq uury}y us tuu|~y }
y}u~~ prp~yu|~u sp~ rurrp|y yquu~y ~utrywy}y } {upyrp, p ~p yx-xp q|uu u} tr
|u~us pup us ur, ~p { {| 4 }|t
q|uz, ~u }wu q yquu~p uw~uz u~u. I}u~~ prp~yu|~u sp~ } xpup r|p pzy{p} {upyrp, uyry} xpqp rz pz, tpwu y|~yu|~} |yp}
tr. I {|yu~p} Cu}up, y pzy{p} {upyrp prp~yu|~}y sp~p}y ~p~uu~ {|p|~z
uq y }puyp|~z, y }p|~z, {z ~y ~p}uu~ rx{p s
tprp. K|{|ur yr RBO B y|u ptpry
p~y{y RBO y t
syu ru~~u. K|{|ur uux tuzry ry ty~u~~
~yxy| ru~~, pu
~ywy yp|~ rpw~u t| ~y {upyr~u sp}}. MBD ry ~pyz quutu| ~u~y { ru~~}. Ix-xp tuzryz }y~yp K|{|urp ~y{ ~u xpu yty |
wy r p}y }
{p qu q
tu xpyp Qty~
, us y}
ur ~y}
t~y{y MBD. Ru} u
|u~yz yu{s CT MBD K|yu~ Cu}up y pzy{y {upyrp Au Buz ptp|y u
~ tuzryz p{ ~pxrpu} prp~yu|uz: upyr~p pqp y |utryu ru|y {ru~~ u
~}
u}. 1. 1 tu{pq |s stp Py}{yz pz~~z
t stp Rp~{-Puuq
sp yx~p| ~uxp{~~}, ~p
py} TPK p{yu{yz {px {upyr
r x~p{}|u~yy }puyp|p}y
s|r~s tu|p. Py p}u~yy tu|p r
tu r~y|, |utru~~p s
p CRT yu{s s|pr{p MBD, }p|~
{rty}p xp}~pp|~y{p CRT |{r~y{} yyy @.N. By~{
r}, p p{yu{y t|{r~y{} yyy E.@. Rpurz, ttu|p|p t{
}u~. @r ttu|{y Rpurp uu r urp|u q|p
r|u~p yx CRT qru~~}
wu|p~y. T|yu~~p ptr{pp}y {upyrp r ~p
u~yy TPK, |utru~~p s
p pry|p y} q
tr|uru~yy tppzrp xpt~y} y|} y p|p utpry tu| p{, {upyr ~u |
y| y} ruz ry~u. Lw q|p rr|u~p r } y|u y } yu} |u{~~s t{
}u~qp yu{s s|pr{p MBD. 2. Pttu|{p t{
}u~r q|p r~
wtu~~} u
|u~yu} t| {y q|uu uux~s: ~uxp{~~s tuwp~y t pwuz. R|utru~~p s
p s
q ~p
y|p prp spwtp~{y yr y ruy{r, }
qux s ~p
u~y ~p ~u
u|p xp 30
{ t yuu~y utu|~s {p tuwp~y uru qry~u} t pwuz ~pp x~p{}|u~yu qry~u} }puyp|p}y tu|p p q| uty~ru~~u ~rp~yu t|u~y y} {p tuwp~y t pwuz ru utu|~s. R|utru~~p s
p yx-xp u{y tpwu |{} ~u }s|p xpruy |utru~~u tuzry, ~uxp{~~ ru|p pp||u|~u p|utrp~yu uxur~}
tu|
, ~ xt~uu, qyr t, yx-xp
ry }puyp|p t| pr|u~y ~
w~s qry~yu|~s xp{|u~y, ~uxp{~~ t|wy|p p|utrp~yu ~r~s tu|p, r } y|u rty|p |utru~~u tuzry, {u, s|p~ TPK, ~urx}w~ |u ~pp|p x~p{}|u~y qry~u} }puyp|p}y tu|p. Bu y
yu~y q|y ~uqty} t| s, q ~y r {u} |
pu ~u r
{p qry~u} y t|wp tuwp y r xp|w~y{p. 3. Du-p{ yty
s|r~u ~p{pxp~yu ~u
wtu~~ |tuz uru t
ty}
wu trp |ry~z stp yt r }u. Py } ~p{pxrp r~ ~y r u} ~ury~~u |ty u~yu{yu
t~y{y Lpz-yx-C
t: tpwu u|y ut|wy, tuzryu|~ pqp|p yp}ytp ruspu {pxp~y}y rytuu|uz p}s qry~u~y, {u qp
t
, {}p~y Cu}u pqp|p, ~y q|y tr|~ |
pu}} tt}, p q|u} ~pp|y |u s, {p{ yz{p |puw~p yu}p {}p~yy q|p q
u~p xpruqrp~~} |yyuz uuq
s{y} ypt}y~} {}p~yy Npqzu~{. Bu t
ty}u u~yu{yu
t~y{y {}p~yy Lpz-yx-C
t y ~y { {p{y}
pr|u~u{y} uu~y} ~u~y ~y{stp ~u y}u|y. I rx|y r xp|w~y{y t| s, q ~y tp|y {pxp~y ~p
{rtr {}p~yy. 4. Eu t~ u
|u~yu xprut} t|w~u p~r|u~yu
{rtyu| |utru~~z s
@.N. By~{
rp yr|uu~yy {upyrp Au Buz r {puru spwtp~{s ruy{p ~p 16 }|t
q|uz, stp {p{
}}p
uqp r
s|r~} tu|u 282 }|~, y r tu|u ~u ~y t~s y{rs xpr|u~y tpwu ~p 100
q. 5. R|utryu y}
|yrp| tr
qu~~ p{yr~ p{ ~pxrpu} uury ~pyp xpr|u~y }p|~}
uqu ~p }y||ypt (!)
q|uz {pwtu y{|yu|~ t| |w~s q~rp~y pup p{yrr {upyrp, ~ ~~, ~yw~u t{
}u~, p{ {p{ }p|~z
uq r ru |
p, ~u rxp~~ yy~u~yu} }uy, y
wtpu yz{y}y
tp}y r px}uu ~u q|uu tu{r
q|uz. 6. Ny ty~ yx uury ~u t{pxp| q~rp~~ ry uu~xyz r spwtp~{}
tu. Py } purp~ p{yr {upyrp y ~p 4 }|t
q|uz y p{yr p~ |y ~p p{
wu
}}
. ^ ~u y~u, {p{ {p xprpp p{yrr y
pyy sp~r r~
u~~y tu| ~u{z xpy~uurp~~z s
z {|yu~r Cu}up ~uqxpu|~ yx y|p uury, u {
y~~u u
|u~yu, {u
~ ys~y
u CTRA MBD Qyy y K|{|ur ry}y xp}p}y ~u} ~p ~ut~{p~u qpu~y. Mup~yx} t| p{s xprpp u uutpp utr t
pr|u~yu Uutup|~s quru~~-s
tpru~~s ~tp xpyu pr r{|pty{r y p{y~ur. P~~, u}
~u sp~yyrp p{yrp}y t
ty} y qry~u}: s ~utp~ t|
tr|uru~y puyr u, { y xp xp{px~}
s|r~} tu|}. I ~~, u}
t~ ytyu{u |y {upyr Au Buz ~uxp{~~ p yr|u { ruru~~y xp t
su {}p~y Cu}u: p{yr Cu}up xp
quw}. 7. R|utryu, p uu y {
p
p rup uu t~ u
|u~yu: ~uxp{~~
tuwyrpu utrp pzy{r {upyrp, {pxrp y ru~
, u rup yu~yu. Wpr |wy B|pty}yp K|{|urp MBD y y}{~
rp { ~u}
{
p
p rup ~pyu uuyy yr uty~y}pu|uz, ru~~, yp|~ ~uxpyu~~ |tuz uuyy, {p{ r 1937 st
. Py } }py~p MBD tuzr
u ~p ~ru |w~ rutu~yz
{rtyu| |utru~~z s
tu|
|{r~y{p yyy By~{
rp, qrus
{rtyu| |utru~~z s
t|{r~y{p yyy Rpurz, u
|~}u~~s T^AyPK yu{s s|pr{p MBD }pzp |yyy Mpur{s. P|{r~y{ y t|{r~y{
pr| su~up|} |yyy Qyz{z Uutupyy? K|{|ur {p{ }y~y}
} | {~|y
u ty~u~~, {u px qyx~u y |tuz. O~y xp~ |{ p|yy{pyuz
s|r~ tu| u| r}spu|rp y y|xrp~y ry |~}yz t| ~p|~u~y qru~~ {p}p~r. Ix-xp ~u
}u|s
{rtrp ~ K|{|urp y us {}p~t, us y}u~yy r
}u~yy {~|yrp ty~u~~
wu y stp |yu~ rqt ~ury~~u |ty, {u y~y|y |x
y t
sy} |t}, y ruz p~u. By~{
rp, Rpur
, Mpur{s y y ~pp|r ~
w~ yxrp { ru
xp p|yy{py
s|r~s tu|p: ~ t|w~uz y pty ~p {p} t
ty} xp ~uxp{~~u tuwp~yu ~ury~~ |tuz r }u, ~uxp{~~u yr|uu~yu {
s|r~z ruru~~y, spq|u~yu yz{s qyx~up,
~ywu~yu yp|~ sp}},
~ywu~yu
p~y{r RBO y t
sy ru~~, p p{wu tu{r yz{y spwtp~! |
|